SCHOOL SPIRIT is like a slasher knockoff of The Breakfast Club. Also, it’s a movie in the Hulu original horror anthology series Into the Dark. Has this anthology run its course and is officially out of ideas? If this is all we can expect, then maybe so. Read our full School Spirit review here.

School Spirit is the latest installment of Into the Dark – the Hulu horror anthology series that releases a new movie each month.

I first came across Into the Dark in March. Up to that point, I was enjoying it. The Body did not disappoint. Flesh & Blood excitingly pitted an agoraphobic daughter against her creepy father (naturally played by Dermot Mulroney). Pooka!, Down, and I’m Just F*cking With You were also well made. I had high hopes for Into the Dark.

And then May happened.

Its installment, All That We Destroy, was… good. Its provocativeness, casting, and acting warranted 3 out of 5 stars, but it started to encroach on stories told by other, older, and, well, better films. Shouldn’t a horror film be at least creepier than the amount that other horror stories’ motifs and themes creep into it?

But I digress. This review is about School Spirit (the August installment of Into the Dark).

And it’s as if Into the Dark has run out of ideas.

A slasher knockoff of The Breakfast Club

Hulu describes School Spirit as “A group of social outcasts stuck in weekend detention is confronted by the school’s legendary hauntings.”

Now, you may be thinking: “This sounds a lot like The Breakfast Club… Oh, it’s a horror version of The Breakfast Club? Got it. But, wait, I thought horror versions of The Breakfast Club have already been done…”

Because they have.

At least twice.

School Spirit tells the story of 5 Helbrook High School students in Saturday detention, supervised by their verbally abusive vice principal. Supposedly, Helbrook is haunted by… a school spirit (no pun intended), a ghost that “takes” the bad kids.

However, the students’ skepticism of a school haunting subsides upon witnessing bloodied hallways, hidden passages, louder-than-normal creaks in the pipes, and the spirit itself.

Into The Dark: School Spirit Review

But it’s not even the best horror version of The Breakfast Club

Now, The Breakfast Club was a phenomenal film. But high school is (slightly) different than it was in 1985, so presumably, in School Spirit there was a lot of room to maneuver with respect to portrayals of students, detentions, and teachers.

Unfortunately, such maneuvering did not happen.

School Spirit is not even the first attempt at a horror version of The Breakfast Club. Bad Kids Go To Hell was a horror/dark comedy version (ultimately thriving by casting Judd Nelson from The Breakfast Club as the school’s headmaster).

Deadly Detention is another example and that one was more of a spoof. Unfortunately, School Spirit took itself too seriously and tried to be a true slasher film, albeit a run-of-the-mill one that did little to impress.

Watch School Spirit on Hulu now

Despite these cons, School Spirit did have its perks.

First, while the boring screenplay’s “twist” came 20 minutes too early, the actors did a very nice job making the most of their roles. Especially the five main actors: Annie Q. (“Erica”), Jessi Case (“Lizzy”), Philip Labes (“Russ”), Julian Works (“Vic”), and Corey Fogelmanis (“Brett”).

Second, the actors looked of reasonable high school age. And, third, K-Ci & JoJo’s “All My Life” is featured toward the end of the film.

Despite these positive elements, School Spirit gets 2 out of 5 stars. About halfway into the film, I thought “this is a 3-star movie”. Alas, I came to regret such optimism. I do hope that the quality of School Spirit is the floor for Into the Dark.

According to Wikipedia, September’s Into the Dark installment is called Pure, in which “several teen girls at a Purity Retreat participate in a secret ritual, and they start to see a supernatural entity. The girls need to focus on the demon that they have unleased, as well as their father’s expectations.”

Welp. I won’t hold my breath.

School Spirit was released on Hulu on August 2, 2019.


Director: Mike Gan
Stars: Annie Q., Corey Fogelmanis, Jessi Case, Julian Works, Jordan Austin Smith, Philip Labes, Hugo Armstrong, Graham Taylor


A group of social outcasts who are stuck in weekend detention are confronted by the school’s legendary hauntings.

Cognitive neuroscientist by day, avid horror fan by night, I began writing reviews/recaps for Heaven of Horror in March 2019. I have a particular affinity to found-footage horror, but I truly love all horror subgenres. As a diagnosed sufferer of obsessive-compulsive disorder, horror movies help relieve my anxieties (and apparently, there's some science to support that). My favorite horror films/shows include Let the Right One In, Hell House LLC, Host, Tucker & Dale vs. Evil, The Babysitter, The Haunting of Hill House, and so many more. I'm very particular about a film's originality when I write reviews, and I hope to steer y'all in the right directions when it comes to which movies to stream versus skip. Happy viewing!
Andrew T. Marshall
Latest posts by Andrew T. Marshall (see all)