R.L. STINE’S PUMPKINHEAD 2 on Tubi is back with returning characters and cast members, with an awesome new addition. Cassandra Peterson plays a key role in the sequel, which also teases yet another movie lined up for 2027. Read our full R.L. Stine’s Pumpkinhead 2 movie review here!
R.L. STINE’S PUMPKINHEAD 2 continues the Halloween family horror on Tubi. This sequel is set almost a year after the events of the first movie. Most of the cast is back – well, those who survived – but the real treat of Pumpkinhead 2 is that Cassandra Peterson (the iconic Elvira) has joined the cast.
As much as I do enjoy these R.L. Stine adaptations, I also recognize that they are made for a family audience and not hardcore horror fans. Sure, you may enjoy the nostalgia of it, but if you don’t, please recognize that they weren’t made for you. Instead, this is how you get the next generation hooked on horror.
Continue reading our R.L. Stine’s Pumpkinhead 2 movie review below. Find it on Tubi now.
Life goes on in Redhaven
With the ending of the first Pumpkinhead movie on Tubi, we ended things on a very dark note. The main character, Sam, ended up being forgotten by his family. His efforts to save others resulted in a curse that caused this. Suddenly, those who loved and had spent his life with him had no idea who he was.
As a result, he moved in with Rusty, who had lost his own sister to the same curse and has effectively become his foster parent. Also, his friend Becka still wants to help him. Other than these two people, life goes on in Redhaven as usual, but nobody knows who he is.
A nightmare for anyone, but especially a child.
In the past year, Sam has been desperately looking for the book of curses, which he believes can undo the curse. Instead of Sam or Becka finding it, the quiet and brutally bullied student Evan discovers the forbidden spellbook. As a result, he awakens the pumpkin-headed children of the town’s past sacrifices.
Give me a movie with Cassandra
There are two amazing additions to Pumpkinhead 2. One is the story about the witch, who has a bad rep despite having never been caught or punished. Well, one could argue she was punished by having to run away.
The other is the addition of Cassandra Peterson (AKA Elvira – Mistress of the Dark), who plays a librarian trying to help Becka. While Sam is digging up entire fields, Becka is trying to find answers in history and knowledge.
Personally, I would love an entire movie with Cassandra Peterson in the lead. I have no idea whether her character is an R.L. Stine creation, and possibly already has her own book as well. If she doesn’t, then surely a spin-off is a possibility.
Watch Pumpkinhead 2 on Tubi now
Jem Garrard (who just recently also gave us Buzzkill) is back writing and directing this Pumpkinhead sequel. I love the vibe, and have no problem recognizing that the choices I may not love are not made for me. I am not the key demographic for this movie; Kids are. As a result, some things are more cartoonish than gory… as they should be!
Also, make sure to pay attention toward the end of this sequel, as it teases yet another R.L. Stine story to be adapted for Tubi. The movie slated for a 2027 release on Tubi is R.L. Stine’s Afraid of Clowns. The director of these two Pumpkinhead movies, Jem Garrard, will be back as a director.
I can understand why – you don’t mess with something that works. While I love Jem Garrard movies that are made for older viewers, who can appreciate the kitsch, camp, and gore, I also love that we’re getting these movies. These R.L. Stine adaptations are great for the whole family to enjoy together during Spooky Season.
R.L. Stine’s Pumpkinhead is out on Tubi on October 9, 2026.
📺 Watch trailer
Plot
When a new Pumpkinhead curse awakens in Redhaven, Sam and Becka must stop it before it claims the entire town.
Details
Director: Jem Garrard
Writer: Jem Garrard
Cast: Bean Reid, Adeline Lo, Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez, Cassandra Peterson
- The Influencer Project – Movie Review (2/5) - November 16, 2026
- Pop Pop – Movie Review (4/5) - November 15, 2026
- Heartland – Movie Review | Netflix (3/5) - November 13, 2026


